Out of the three, I definitely prefer the Bell & Carlson Carbelite. I've used all three....the B&C is a classic styled stock, with a slimmer fore end than the other two. I have small hands, so I like the tight grip and slimmer fore end. The Hogue has a beaver tail forearm, meaning that it's wide and full. That stock is too thick and heavy for a sporter rifle in my opinion, but if you want something that's going to be a stable shooting platform, it will do well. The HS is the highest price of the three, and I still haven't decided if I like them or not. I've had a couple of Remington Police rifles and they worked well on those guns. I think that they feel, well, pregnant is the best thing I can think of. They just don't feel as good in my hands as the B&C stocks do. Also, the B&C stocks are solid throughout, and you can work with them like a wooden stock. I've not used the B&C Medalist stocks, they have the full bedding block. I like the have my rifles glass bedded, so I skip the aluminum block and use the money I save to pay for the bedding. All the rifles that I've put them on shot very well, as good or better than before (whether or not they were bedded). For the $$$, I think that they are the best deal on the market.
