Windcutter:
You didn't mention what if any wad that you were using. you need a wad between the bullet and powder. I tried the CSA bullet in my 40-65 Pedersoli. I didn't have good luck. I like RCBS molds so I changed to the 400 BPS, which I believe my hero Mike Venturino designed. This bullet has large, deep square grease grooves for a lot of lube. I load about 62grs Goex cartridge with a drop tube, compressed, a .030" fiber wad. Star-line brass, a federal 215 primer. And oh yes lubed with SPG lube. I don't understand what your doing with the Bore Butter? I seat my bullet right in the lands. Also it is very important to use a blow tub to keep fowling soft between shots.
I had about a three year learning curve on this black powder stuff. But I think it is the most fun you can have legally. If you can, try to shoot 200 yds or longer. my rifle is more accurite at 200 or 300 yards than 100. The range we shoot at, we can shoot 550 yds. I haven't been able to shoot any matches because of church on sundays. I hope this helps
Jim