Steve,
It depends on your definition of overpriced, but, you should also take a look at the Ballard High Walls, they are 100% copies of the original 1885 patent. The base model sells for $2050 with FET included, while the C-Sharps is around $1350 before FET. The FET will bring the C-Sharps up to about $1500. Both companies will chamber in 30-40 Krag, and both are using Badger barrels.
C-Sharps does make nice rifles, but between the C-Sharps and Ballards Ive seen, Id give the edge to the Ballard. They also have a greater list of options, and make a Thin Side action. Some of the options that C-Sharps is charging for are freebies with Ballard, such as barrel configurations, and barrel sights even (C-Sharps wants $85 for a set of buckhorns).
Ive got two Ballard High Wall Special Sporting Rifles, and have been very pleased with them. My only problem is now convincing my wife I need a Low Wall .22 to practice with.
Chuck