I have not hit a deer in the shoulder with the PB aerotip but I have with a 30-06 with, I suspect, similiar results; no pass through, a wounded deer that I was, luckily, able to find and finish off with a neck shot. Clearly shot placement is important no matter what you're hunting with. I've killed deer with a 54 cal hawken, with a round ball and a 50 cal TC Black Diamond, with TC sabots, both of which are fine set-ups but for overall ease of loading, maintenance, accuracy and power, I have to say that the combination of the CVA Kodiak Pro and PB 295 aerotips is my favorite.