IIRC, there was a pretty comprehensive article in one of the gun rags, about twenty years ago, covering around fifty different types of wood and how they would rate as satisfactory gunstock material.
I seem to remember Oak as being both too heavy and plain, and cherry as just too plain - but I could be wrong, as it's been awhile since I read the article.
IMHO, the Cherry's more doable than Oak.
In any event, as I remember, any standing tree, cut down for stock wood, needs to have oversized blanks, with the ends painted/sealed, slow-dried over a long period of time (some woods took years) to develop the right moisture content and avoid future warping/checking after final shaping.