Imagine that all rifles and calibers were banned (or never made) except for a bolt action .30-06. Would any hunter (in the US) really be hindered?
It depends on what your definition of "hindered" is. While the .30-'06 is, hands down, my favorite centerfire rifle cartridge, and while I would confidently hunt all over the world with it if I had the means to do so, it is gross overkill for some of the smaller, sub 125 pound game animals that I hunt. Still, if I could only have a bolt action .30-'06, I'd be in great shape, because if the conventional wisdom says I need more gun than this to take a given animal, I probably don't have any interest in killing said animal in the first place. All of the stuff that I am interested in taking can be taken with the old "ought six."
Imagine that all rifles and calibers were banned (or never made) except for a (any) action .30-30. Would any hunter (in the US) really be hindered?
This would definitely cramp my style. I sometimes need something with a flatter trajectory and I think that even the .30-30 is overkill for some of the smaller varieties of big game that I hunt, while lacking in the ooomph department on the bigger stuff that I might want to hunt again.
Imagine that all rifles and calibers were banned (or never made) except for a bolt action .243. Would any hunter (in the US) really be hindered?
Hmmm.... If I focus on the vast majority of hunting that I do currently and am likely to do in the immediate future, and not on the hunting that I have done and would very much like to do again, being limited to a .243 probably wouldn't cramp my style too much. It wouldn't be gross overkill on smaller deer, pronghorns, and similarly sized critters, and with some component bullet that could dig in deep, I could probably make it work on larger game animals over 400 pounds on the hoof, if it was all that I had. Assuming, of course, that I still have access to Barnes X bullets........
I could go on here...insert caliber...down to .223 and its short comings on animals deer size and up and .300 Win mag and up with recoil, ammo price/availability, etc.
If I focus on the hunting that I do in my home county, the .223 is all the rifle I need, as the biggest thing I am likely to shoot is a whitetail weighing less than 125 pounds.
-JP