Bill,
I like the idea of the revolver and own quite a few. i have a colt Det spl and have shot it in a steel shoot. When I win the previous month I shoot a compact handgun the next month. My concern is that 38 special out of a 2" gun does not do what a .380 out of a 3" gun will. We have some metal swingers in the club shoot and my 38 out of the 4 or 6 inch revolvers will spin the plate but the same ammo out of the 2" will not and lighter bullets out of my 380 will move the same swingers. They do make short barreled handgun ammo and if your going to carry a sub compact 9, 357 sig, 38, 357, 40, or 45 that you may want to look into as carry ammo.
Just my 2 cents.