To me, a .41 mag Marlin only makes sense if you already have a .41 revolver and you want a companion for it. The recoil of a .44 mag rifle is (to me) very light and manageable. So I'd step up to the .44 with it's much better ballistics. BUT...I sure like the better control of the .41 mag in a revolver...man, this gets complicated, doesn't it.