I have a few scopes with illuminated reticles and I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THEM!! :-D
Specifically, I have (2) Leupold Vari-X III 4.5x-14x-50mm Illuminated AO, Bushnell Elite 4200 2.5x-10x-50mm Illuminated, and Nightforce NXS 5.5x-22x-56mm Illuminated Mil-Dot.
Some people say that illuminated reticles are cheating. Others say that they are of little or no use during legal shooting times.
Well let me tell you, as for "cheating," it's not. If it allows me to make a cleaner shot, then it's not cheating...it's ethical.
As for not being useful during legal shooting times, it also isn't true. Have you ever been hunting on very overcast days? On such days it is very dark well before legal shooting times have expired. Also, if you hunt heavily wooded areas, it is difficult to discern your crosshairs from some of the branches that, at a distance, also look black like your crosshairs. Light-up the reticle and you can see perfectly.
For me, the bottom line is that I will only buy scopes with illuminated reticles from now on. My problem is that I now don't use my other rifles that have non-illuminated scopes.
Just one note, illuminated reticles are illegal in some states. Check your state's regulations.
Zachary