My vote is for the Ruger Bearcat. Lightwt, handy, perfect for woods walking! I also have an old Charter Pathfinder with the 3" bbl. Picked it up for $125, shoots great and fits all the holsters made for 3" J framed smiths. You can often find these for a song at the gun shows. One I wish I had back is an aluminum frame Colt Scout. Light and handy, mine was a great shooter but I had a stupid attack and sold it.