Like Danny discovered, IF you take the rifle AND the handgun ,YOU will grab the rifle. I had this same trouble when I first started using the handgun. I went thru a period where I carried a 44 Ruger SBH AND a 14" T/C in holsters,grabbing the SBH for quick, close shots. Eventually I settled on taking one or the other depending on the area to be hunted. I had/have several 14" barrels to choose from and MAY have missed a close deer or 2 ,but it was still fun to HUNT for the deer instead of waiting to snipe it.