I've aquired a fair number of sporterized military surp rifles that needed some TLC. So, most of them have been redone with cold blue. Some turned very nice, some so so. Blue Wonder has been the most reliable for doing a decent to very good job on barrels, receivers, trigger guards.....smaller items like screws and such I prefer to dip in Oxpho Blue. Oxpho Blue can give good results on barrels and ect too, just prefer the Blue Wonder. I've tried other brands of cold blue, but found they just didn't work as well or weren't as durable.