Well to be honest, I really haven't found any one to be great with both field points and broadheads. I usually shoot my field points into one of the bag type targets, like this one,
What ever you do don't shoot any broadheads into this type target, least wise any you want back or unless you feel like filleting the target open like you see the holes in mine to get them out.
I usually use one of the American Whitetail King targets for my broadhead shooting only as the field pointed arrows will not hardly come out of it.
This said, when I do limited shooting of both as in tuning or simply to check out how well a BH might fly I use one of the Block targets like this,
The Block pictured here was pretty new then, but now is going on it's third year, and I do admit that there are a couple of places it has been shot up pretty well by BH's, but overall if you spread the places you shoot out similar to what I have done with the earplugs, you will find that they all will last much longer.