How did you make out with Lyman customer service, are they going to make this right with you. I would not let it drop, just because some flunky in the call center is having a bad day.
I have never had to with reloading companies, but Sears before I got totally fed up with them got several letters from me to corporate.
After enough complaining they made it right with me.
Not so much the price of the replacement handle, but it should not have broke in the first place.
Obvious defective part.