After trying all the possibilities with my Contenders and other handguns I settled on cross draw for the short barreled ones. Not as prone to snag in brush, protects the firearm better, most comfortable to wear all day, especially on horse back or if in and out of a vehicle. I had mine custom made out of leather just because I prefer leather, and they were slotted to accept those scoped, but one from the nylon materials would be as good or better.
HTH-YMMV
L.