I have always shot 150's out of my 30-06. Recently I have taken a liking to shooting my Remmy 760 with a peep sight. I got to thinking this would make an awesome short range woods gun. would 180's be a better choice for anchoring a deer where it stood or would they lack the expansion needed. Also, what about the old 180 round nose bullet. I have no experience with them on game, but I am wondering.
Mike
I have shot my .30'06 for many years. I have yet to find a bullet weight that isn't just the best for what I wanted it to do when shot out of the '06. Though the '06 wouldn't make my list of Essential Calibres, that's more a measure of my personal bias as a statement against the grand ole .30'06.
These days I do most of my hunting with the 165 gr Barnes TSX loaded into the '06. But I have a friend that just loves the 180 gr (BT) bullet for most everything. I reload for accuracy and performance in my firearm, and the 165 and the 180 both will have very good down range performance. And you with your 180 gr (BT) will most likely out perform my 165 gr BT in terminal ballistics at the other end.
If you are looking for a short Range Hammer in your .30'06...maybe consider something like a 220 gr round nose bullet for your open sited rifle. Its not going to reach out there as efficiently as your 180 gr (BT) bullet, but with open sites on your gun....you'll have no care for long range shooting anyway. Open site, most of your shots will be less than 200 yards. I'd take a 220 gr projectile, loaded in my '06, on a thick cover heavy brush
Moose Hunt and have no fear about being under gunned.