Background: I do have not shot much competitively, but have enjoyed shooting recreationally for years. My first hunting rifle was a Competitor pistol some 20 years ago. In my barrel collection are a .223 (10 or 12) and a .308 (14 or 16). I am not exactly sure on the lengths (might try to find them tonight).
My kids shoot somewhat competitively in 4H. In the past they have been shooting a smallbore pistol in smallbore hunter pistol class. It has worked ok for them in the past but I also know that a dedicated hunter pistol (and the taco hold) would be more competitive. They mostly shoot iron sights.
Other factors: There are several additional clubs we could shoot at both NRA and IHMSA. I have not shot at either so do not know their cultures (I do know the NRA one has some crossover with their local 4H club). I also am not opposed to having a new hog hunting pistol (thinking a suppressed 300 blackout).
FWIW I am planning on shopping over the holiday weekend and highly suspect I will be seeing a quite a few Contenders and barrels, and perhaps a few Competitor barrels as well.
Questions and un-validated assumptions:
I dont know if I could make the Competitor competitive in smallbore hunter class. I dont immediately see how to get a Williams site to fit (for taco hold) and worry it will be overweight after the effort. It might or might not squeak by with a 10 barrel and a Ken Light rib (assuming that will fit). I suspect going with a Contender is the best option-using the Williams sight designed for direct fit (any G1 vs G2 issues).
Not sure how much steel is left on the table if I go with a 10 barrel rather than a 12 barrel for 4H and NRA competitions. I am under the impression that the shorter barrel has the advantage of being IHMSA legal (are peeps smallbore IHMSA legal?).
I do not know if my 308 is legal for anything (barrel length (over 15), target damage rules) Not sure if my .223 is useful for anything (potential barrel length (if 12) and target damage rules). I understand that none of them (nor the 300 blackout) would be legal for hunter pistol but what considerations should I keep in mind if I get a new barrel (and length or caliber considerations). Should I focus on the Contender or Competitor?
Any suggestions would be appreciated.