Just so you know, or anyone else reading this on down the road, a bullet that is cast too hard for the impact velocity can shatter as you described. But if you soften it up some, it will perform like a proper hunting bullet and expand. Now having said that, if you go too soft, it won't be strong enough to survive the trip down the bore with the rifling causing it to twist, and you will get some leading, so you have to find a happy medium. I use range scrap with a handful of wheel weights thrown in to harden it up in mine. The bullet is hard enough to not lead my bore, yet soft enough to deform very slightly if I accidentally roll one of these off the counter ( about 3.5-4 ft) amd they land on the tile in my kitchen. So they're fairly soft, but I don't have a hardness tester to give an actual measurement of hardness. And like I said, mine leaded up badly no matter how hard the bullets were til I started sizing to .311" and since then, I can shoot them as soft as I want and not worry about it.