I don't think that you will have too much problem with the Redington. I don't really know about the Cabela's graphite fly rods, but I have heard some guys who prefer moderate action rods who think that the 3 Forks Rods are a terrific value for even 4 times the money. For the economical reels, I like the Cabela's graphite reels. No, it isn't the same as a $100+ reel, but it is light, durable, and you can't beat it for $20 and spare spools are only $9. I like having the palming ring on the spool, and just haven't ever really liked the Medalist reels, but that is just a personal preferance. I've started building up my own rods, and have since become less than enthusiastic about the Orvis, T&T, Sage or other big name, big dollar gear. I've found that equivalent or superior performing blanks can be built up for a fraction of the price that the big boys require.