Congratulations on your successful hunt! I am hopping for some sucess this weekend. I went out the last two days and saw 17 doe. Maybe this weekend I will get a shot.
My buck last year had been in a fight like yours. He had a broken brow tine and the tip of his left beam was mushroomed on the end. If he had not screwed it up I would have mounted him. Well, at least he tasted good.
Cheers,
Jay