After much thought and a little more reading, I think I'll go with a .308, for more versatility in case I decide to use it for something bigger than deer later, and the larger selection of factory loads (but I'll probably start reloading anyway). I figure if I don't like the recoil, I can install a recoil reducer in the buttstock to make it more comfortable to shoot. The new Brownell's catalog has a good selection of those.
The only other thing is that I would prefer stainless, but it's not available in .308 (or 7mm-08 ). According to the catalog, it looks like they added three calibers to the stainless model this year (none of the ones I want, though). I wonder if I should wait until early next year to see if they add .308 to the list for the stainless model (I won't be able to hunt with it this year anyway, due to time constraints). I asked the customer service people about this when I called the other day, but they say they won't know anything about that until the new catalog is out early next year. I guess the only way to know is to wait and see.
Thanks to everyone for all the advice. I really appreciate the help. :agree: