Well, Miss Molly Morgan likes my Rossi 92 in 44-40, so I reckon she will be using that . I loaded up some ammo with 200 grain bullets and 6grains of Unique that she felt she could handle. The Hogdon site has a load for .44-40 with Tight group, so I may try that in this caliber. I have a birdshead gripped New Dakota in .44-40 as well. She can shoot this gun too, but I am somewhat worried that the light weight will prove a problem. I can get a light load, but it will still recoil a might. I don't want to scare her. She is really into CAS right now, so I don't want to spoil it.