That's a great theory but the poly's have their own set of faults... They are on the wood finishes not in the wood finishes. They set on top the wood and are quite brittle. many have cracks from impacts and most will eventually craze from age and heat. When they're cracked the moisture gets in and the finish lifts and stock moves. You've all seen the cloudy white haze on used Remington 700 rifles.. Maintenance on poly is more like repainting a car.. spot sand, apply the new finish(several coats) and sand level, then polish. A good oil finish with a wax protective coat is nearly as waterproof and is a lot more durable. I've been mucking around with guns and stock work for 35+ years and have tried everything I have found. Tung oil is waterproof and Linspeed is quicker to apply but TrueOil and wax lasts well, is easy to maintain and will shed water like a duck. It won't crack over time and maintaining it is easy... I've a 300 mag on an american enfield that I built 30 years ago to hunt moose with...it looks as good as the day it was finished..well,, the rollover and skipline checkering have lost some of their appeal but the finish is going strong... It's the rifle I take when it's raining and I have to go hunt.. Never moves from year to year and maintenance is simple... The blue is wearing a litle thin on the high spots and there are a few scratches,(it was to Canada twice)but the wood hasn't moved yet!