I cannot comment on the scopes you listed, no experience. If you are using your 44 Mag to hunt deer in SE Ohio, I would suggest the following. I have hunted deer in Muskingum county , and I would suggest an ULTRADOT scope. For the range you suggested, I donot think there is anything that would meet your requirements better, especially if you where glasses, especially bifocals. It has made a world of difference on my 44 Contender. I hope you donot mind my suggestion, I am sure your choices are good ones, but I thought another option may help.