Many people ask this question and compare the Handi to the Encore and Ruger #1. But I don't think it's fair to compare them. Like was mentioned the fit and over all finish on the Encore and Ruger are beautiful, and extremely solid. And the price range isn't anywhere close to a Handi.
Just depends on the intended use, price range, quality, "name"-if that apeals to you, and the amount of comprimise you are willing to work with, of the rifle in question. With slight modifications, they all shoot good and some don't even need that.
Just depends a lot on the individual shooter, as to whats right for him. I didn't vote for either one, they both have their strengths and weaknesses.
If you want a inexpensive rifle, that you are willing to be patient with, and like to tinker, then the Handi is a great choice by any standard.
If you want something to show off at the range and look fantastic with a big name, then the Encore is a great choice.
But you got to admit the look on other peoples face when you whip out a "Humble Handi" and shoot some nice tiny groups is great.
-Aaron