I would add that the 4 5/8 Colt has been a great backup gun for me; even gotten me out of a tight spot or two (of the wild kind.)
Your gun should do 1100-1200 with 300s which won't be easily stopped by most animals.
I would hesitate to say that the muzzle flip will be greater - different, yes. You don't have the great mass of the longer barrel so, while the recoil arc may be a bit faster, it doesn't seem as strong or, consequently, as hard to control. That's how I perceive it. I'm sure that varies from person to person though.
I like my everyday guns to be stainless, but to be honest, when it comes to handguns, I haven't had trouble with my blued ones.