I re-blued an Enfield #4 using Brownells Oxpho Blue. I've used Oxpho on a couple commercial rifles and shotguns and usually end up with a deep, polished blue finish. Under direct light there is usually a silvery tint. Using the same procedure as the others, the Enfield didn't result with the same deep, polished blue. It is more of a dark blue.
My overall experiance with Oxpho Blue is that is is durable and withstands oil and moisture. I've had very good luck with it on a couple of Marlin .22's I picked up at pawn shops. I've found that removing all the old bluing and polishing the metal to the extent that it looked like chrome results in the best finish. The cleaning process is the most important, I believe. The parts to be blued must be clear of all oils and dirt and once cleaned, I don't touch any of the parts with bare hands.
I've used Birchwood Casey Super Blue for touch ups and have been pleased. It seems to be darker than Oxpho, but with small touch up areas, I've had good success by applying, polishing, applying, polishing several times until I can get it to blend pretty good.
I also us an old hand held hair dryer to heat the metal before each application.
Krochus: Very nice job on the Enfield. I like the finish. It looks natural. Beautiful gun! I may try that on a Mosin project, if I ever get it going.
EVOC ONE