Yep, it does depend on --------------------???
I have also owned both of the action types - more of the single actions - but presently own a Redhawk which I really like!!
It is one tough gun!!
When I switched over to the 300+ brain cast bullets, I did have some problem with the cylinder pin on the BH. It tended to move and damage itself with the heavy recoil.
A person could buy an after market pin which should cure that problem, however, the RH just takes a lick'in and keeps on ticken with a steady of diet of 310gr. LBT bullets ahead of 19gr of AA#9.
This load gets me in excess of 1200fps out of my 5 1/2" barrel.
I like the single action, but after owning this double action Red Hawk, it would clearly be my choice for any future selections.
One thing I would do, no matter the style I bought, it would be a barrel no longer then 5 1/2" unless I planned to scope it and carry in a shoulder rig.
I use a left side - butt forward holster for my RH, and even though this is a big/heavy pistol, it is for the most part out of the way until needed.
Keep em coming!