James B wrote,<I had an old H&R 30-30 that didn't shoot well at all but it was really loose>
That can happen to the modern day rifles also, but usually not with the 30-30 as it operates at lower pressures than the newer style rimless versions do.
The 30-30 (Ive had 3, two NEF's and 1 Topper) have all shot well. The 1st 30-30 I had was an NEF and was dead on with any bullet I loaded for it. The second one was given to my son-in-law with a Tracker II barrel as well. The 3rd was a Topper barrel I mated to a new NEF shotgun frame. The whole rig is light to carry and is the only one I ever use to hunt whitetail with. I like it so much I sold the 1st one to a hunting buddy.
The 130 Hornady and the 130 Barnes XBT worked well in all three rifles. My advice is to go with the 30-30 it's a blast to shoot and if you handload (I think you might by your post) it can even be more fun playing with the spitzer bullets The Speer 110 grain SP is fun to shoot also.
Do you still have the old Topper? I might be interested if you have it and would possibly sell it.