you said pipe lead , plumbers have 4 types of lead not including solder , caulking lead , virgin lead , lead pipe and sheet lead . Virgin lead is close to pure , the rest vary in purity , if you look at lead from different companies you can see the difference . Also the lead will be harder from one company vs. another ! some joints we pour when caulked will mark easy others will not , some 25 lb. ingots will ring when you hold them up and hit them some won't . I have been told the harder lead was for water main , but no hard evidence , although it makes sense . i have collected lead for years , and cast bullets for my black powder gun as long all lead srinks when it cools if it didn't it would be hard to free it from the mould . Some mix 50/50 soder to lead 1 to 10 or 1 to 9 mix , 95 /5 works also , i have tried both along with window weights , 60/40 and 40/60 and wheel weights ! they all fit the gun and shot good ! i did not mesure them ! so if the were differen't it was a small amount !