.458 Barnes X and Contender

[FreeNHim]

Has anyone ever loaded 300 Grn Barnes X bullets for 45/70 in a 16 " Contender?  If so, what were the results?  Thanks, Jim

[Bill,SC]

I have used the .458 X for several years.  I use the load recommended in the contender loading manual.  It has never failed to put down a deer instantly.  I can't tell you about the performance of the bullet because I have never recovered one(5 - 120yds).  From the size of the exit hole, it must not expand much.  It does appear to be larger, but not much.  I don't think any of the deer knew that it did not expand.

[FreeNHim]

Hi Bill,

What did you find to be the most accurate load? if you are willing to share...I'd appreciate any guidance you could provide.

Thanks in advance,

Jim

[Bill,SC]

I will locate my load book and give the info to you.  I have just returned from a year out of state.  Therefore, it might take a day or two to locate.  I will tell you that a hard cast bullet did the same thing that the Barnes X did and sure cost a lot less.