I have tried the neoprene gloves and have not had good results, UNLESS, your hands are moving and creating some heat which the neoprene gloves will retain. In most cases I use fingerless wool gloves with a outer mitten of some sort. Don't ask me why but my fingers stay warmer with the fingerless, than with full coverage liners. Or I may wear a heavy mitt on my off hand using, again, a fingerless wool glove on my shooting hand and stick it in my pocket to keep it warm. I have a pair of military surplus finger mits that I use but the finger is to bulky for us with the average gun. An option would be to cut the finger off and velcro it closed for access as needed. I have also used the fold back mitts but the part that folds back always seems to get in the way.