Whats the matter with trophy hunting? I do it all the time but the meat goes to a good cause. I don't think trophy huntin is wrong.
The way I was brought up - meat is meat. You can't eat the antlers.
There is more to brag about if you shoot a spike buck in the middle of the George Washington National Forest than a 10 point in a pen.
All the people that I see on the TV hunting shows - none of them actually earned their deer. All they did was make a nice shot. With camera angles and lenses - they can make a 60 yard shot look like a 300 yards shot. Even then what does it matter because they were hunting in a fence anyways.
My dad always said, if you don't eat the meat, you shouldn't shoot the deer.
Giving it away and then going back out the same day or the next day and trying to shoot another one - just for bragging rights is just being a pig!