Owned them both, and I would have to say that while they are both great machines, the Rancher is the greatest all around machine. Get the 4WD Rancher, and never look back!!!
Also, the Recon is a noticeably smaller machine. I'm only 5'11", and 155 lbs., but felt too large on the Recon. Plus, you will never regret spending the extra dough to have 4WD.
In my extensive experience, and the experience of twenty some riding compatriots, Honda's don't break! We are all on Ranchers! Believe me, we have tried!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/34eee/34eeed6887618c991927e70cfaf500ab5b6a6be4" alt="Grin ;D"