We had a good post going on the Beartooth bullets lever gun page about the 35 Remington and how hot it could go in a Marlin. Since you have so much experience with the 35 Rem. I would love to hear your input on that subject!
Reb
Once knew a dude, who shall remain nameless, rest his soul, who ran nothing but Weatherby rifles. It was not at all out of vouge for him to walk into "Greasy Pete's" Gunshop and walk behind the counter, grab a brand new Wby, and tell the owner he was going out to shoot it. If it shot, he would buy it.
What he put through those rifles for loads would make normal folks, and the ballistics boys cringe and break down in tears. Brass was good for the one fire. The primer was blown out and the cases stuck so bad you had to use a plastic mallet to open the bolt! He was doing 4000 fps when others were just thinking about it. That alone stands testimony that Weatherby does in fact build some phenominaly safe rifles.
Now the guy was an idiot you say. I'd tend to agree. Except for the fact that I have never met another man who could out shoot him! On a good day, the average man wears a huge smile if he busts an inch at 100 yards with hunting loads, and that's off the bench with all the stars lined up. This character could do that at 300 yards...........OFFHAND!
Like everyone else, I got suckered in. You see, he didn't do much bragging about his talent, kept it kinda quiet if you know what I mean. One day we got out of the truck and he loaded up a 7mm Wby Mark 5. How far you think it is to that sign down by the river he asked. Took me a while to even find it. Has to be some on 700 yards, maybe even 800 I said. Bet I can unload this rifle in it from here. Stupid me, bet what? $10 he sez. Dumber me, I figure he's at least going to lay accross the hood of the truck. No Sir! He stands there and fires one, hammers the bolt open, fires another, kept doing it until the gun was dry. Me, I was already spending the $10!
Took some to get there but I was about 15 yards or so from the sign when I saw the holes. I'm tellin it straight boys, there was 4 new clean holes in that board inside of a 3inch inch group, plumb center. Figured he staged it, must have shot it before we got there close up and missed em all from where we were. So now I bet him $20 he can't do it again. He smiles. We go back, he lights em up again. We walk, I pay! Never seen the likes of it.
So what's the moral to the story, load em hot? For him, he could pretty much do what he wanted, he obviously went beyond safe, knew what he was doing, and it worked for him.
Me, I'm getting the jitters when I see a primer get flatish. The load I called out above for the 35 Rem comes out of the chamber at the same temp it went in at. 50 cases would last a man a lifetime of reloading with that load. It never made much sense to me to try an get a 35 Rem to equal a 35 Whelen, just never was intended to do that.
If I had to guess, I'd say I have shot ..........hmmm, been a lot of years, a lot of guns, maybeso 5000 different rifles. Ran handloads in most of em too. If someone was to put me in a corner and ask for a load RIGHT NOW on account of they got no time to work one up, they're going huntin, and regardless of caliber, I would say pull a reloading manual for the maker of the bullet, drop the max load 2 grains and go hunting. Of course I'd reccomend they sight in with the load :wink:
Each gun is different, there are a lot of variables to consider. But if you do it enough, you find pet loads that work in 99% of the rifles in a given caliber. You know it so well that the 1% that won't perform are turkys and you dump em early in the game.
A buck deer that gets hit in the lungs with a 200 grain Remington Core Lokt, out as far as 125 yards or so, maybe 150 on a good day, well, he's going to be meeting his Maker in right short order I do not believe that another 200 fps is going to get him there any faster. Another 1000 fps, maybeso, but then you aren't going to get that much no matter how much you push the envelope in that particular rifle.
There are all kinds of folks that make up the ranks we call ourselves as hunters. Being honest, there are not many real riflemen left among us. Can't be, we all spend our lives working full time, hunting part time, except GB
Take a look at the deer in the butcher shop, where are they hit? All dead center lung shots? Some have broken legs, some hit in the hams, some ripped out spines, some even shot in the throat! Are we to assume that's where the hunter was aiming?
A shot can go bad for a host of reasons. Flinching is a big one, but of course none of us do it. Interviening brush, the game moved, or maybe it had made you and is all pumped up with adrenalin. Lot involved in clean killing. What we hope for, the perfect one shot in tracks kill does happen, but not as often as we'd like.
And when it DON'T happen, it's never OUR fault, had to have been the gun, the load, the bullet. Maybe if I'd a had a 300WSM instead of this -06 it would have killed em square. Nah, good shooting is good shooting and bad is bad.
Long as I've been alive, Remington has had some of the best bullets out there in as far as performance on game. They can be beat in the accuracy department, but then they never were designed to be match bullets. Think about it, nobody equaled them until folks like Trophy Bonded came along and started fusing cores to jackets. Remington had it right a long time ago. Now even Remington recognizes the market for the premium bullet and they load Scirocos in their brass. Truth be known, both perform the same in game, one just costs a heck of a lot more than the other.
Jacket/core separation in game bullets can be a BIG problem, especially on the larger stuff, critical on the dangerous stuff. That's why Nosler went to his Partition, that's why Hornady Interlocks em, that's why Speer hot cores em, that's why they get bonded or fused.
Out of all of it, the bullet is what gets the job done. It must be accurate enough to stay in the vitals, and it has to behave properly to get the job done right.
For my 2 cents, focus on that, and let the velocity land where it may. I'll keep mine to the cool side. Besides, if you ever buy a gun from me, you'll know it hasn't had the metal stressed from hoss loads :lol:
Coug