the tab only helps eliminate jams , the 5 shot 870 bbl should fit . The "field" model had a 4 shot mag that allowed only 4 shots and the loop that rides over the magazine tube is in the wrong place . The first 20 ga's were built on 12 recivers and thus take a different bbl than the newer ones . I believe all 12 ga bbls except the "field" Mod will work even the 3.5 bbl . Its the reciver that dictates the length shell you need to use . I know of several 2 3/4 recivers that were reworked to shoot 3 inch shells and more than a few 2 3/4 bbls that were re-chambered to 3 inch. I have one old gun that came with the thin wall bbls ( before steel shot ) and the new heavy wall bbls fit it and its bbl fits the new reciver .