Hi Bobg,
Nope...never hunted Tioga. I have had a number of relatives who have, an Uncle of mine shot a 365lb boar with a bow and had a good trip. Another relative goes every 3-4 years on the way home from his almost annual Pennsi deer hunt. I suspect it's put and take, so I'm not at all interested in driving from MASS.
My experience to date on preserve and wilderness hunts is that you meet all kinds of characters. "Farkels" I call'm...y'know the type...all the newest gear, at least 2 guns, 50-60 rounds of ammo for each and a BIG knife....and they never seem to lose sight of the road.......
I don't expect TIOGA is on my list of places to hunt.