I have both - 3 Stevens 200's and 2 Handi frames with 6 barrels. I think it depends on personal likes, preferences and needs. If I am going big bear hunting, I want a repeater - 'nuff said about that. If I am shooting varmints I prefer a single shot rifle I believe in one well placed shot and it helps keep the barrel cooler.- I have converted 2 out of the 3 Stevens 200 into single shots. I have a tenancy to change what ever gun I am using. Some times just a bedding job, but some times a custom stock, different barrel and more than likely a modified or different trigger. Even Handi's I have changed (worked on). Bottom line - I can get Handi's to shoot well, I can get Stevens to shoot well. I think the Stevens are for the most part more accurate out of the box, if you do not want to do any thing at all. There are exceptions to every rule when it comes to guns. I have heard of Handis shooting very well right out of the box, with out changing a thing. I have also heard of having accuracy problems with a Stevens and then having to do accuracy work on it to get it to shoot well. If you do not mind tinkering with a gun ( I do) get the Handi rifle, chances are you will want a trigger job if nothing else. If you do not want to do any thing with the gun, get a Stevens, the trigger is not the best, but is serviceable. I think there is a better chance of getting a great shooting rifle out of the box. This is unless you need follow up shots for safety sake.