There's mucho confusion about "Ironwood".
Blue Beech, Muscle Wood, Water Beech (usually the same tree) are called "Iron Wood" around here. Hop Hornbeam and American Hornbeam are also called Iron wood around here. I fell them in the woodlot to burn in the stove. I've also been burning my Locust fence posts, since we stopped running beef. Now that's a hard wood. Tough to drive a staple in. Anything that burns better 'n snow, goes in the woodshed.
Some of these woods were supposed to have been used for wagon parts, e.g. the tongue. The trees never attained great size (Hornbeam 10 inch max) so I doubt they were ever used for a single limber shaft or cannon trail. Oak being plentiful and a single tree being able to offer numerous boards/beams for carriages.
I don't think they're anything worth pickin' over for our purpose; minature or otherwise.
Rich,
You mentioned rosewood being hard to work; the only thing I've ever done with rosewood was to try and 'sharpen up' the checkering on some inexpensive repro Luger P08 grips with a knife edge needle file, and that project didn't turn out too good.
The reason I asked the question about lignum v. was because I wanted to know if you had ever worked with what are classed as the "ironwoods," the hardest wood that I've ever cut and sanded was southern live oak, and that was some hard stuff, but it's not even classed as an ironwood.
Hardwoods "But of all the so-called "hardwoods," the most spectacular species are the "ironwoods" that actually sinks in water. Fifteen[sic] of the world's heaviest ironwoods with specific gravities between 1.11 and 1.37 are listed in the following Table 2. All of these seasoned, dry hardwoods will sink in water, with a specific gravity greater than one:
Lignum Vitae
(Guaiacum officinale) Caltrop
(Zygophyllaceae) S.E. U.S. &
Caribbean 1.37
Snakewood
(Piratinera guianensis) Mulberry
(Moraceae) South
America 1.35
Leadwood
(Krugiodendron ferreum) Buckthorn
Rhamnaceae S. Florida
and Keys 1.31
Burma Ironwood
(Xylia xylocarpa) Legume
(Fabaceae) India
Burma 1.29
Quebracho
(Schinopsis balansae) Sumac
Anacardiaceae Argentina
S. America 1.28
Womara
(Swartzia leiocalycina) Legume
Fabaceae British
Guiana 1.28
Wawra
(Combretum imberbe) Combretum
(Combretaceae) Zimbabwe
South Africa 1.23
Billian
(Eusideroxylon zwageri) Laurel
(Lauraceae) Borneo
Malaysia 1.20
Pau d'Arco
(Tabebuia serratifolia) Bignonia
(Bignoniaceae) Brazil
S. America 1.20
Knob-thorn
(Acacia nigrescens) Legume
(Fabaceae) South
Africa 1.19
Brazil Ironwood
(Caesalpinia ferrea) Legume
(Fabaceae) Brazil
S. America 1.15
Desert Ironwood
(Olneya tesota) Legume
(Fabaceae) S.W. U.S.
Mexico 1.15
Ceylon Ironwood
(Mesua ferrea) Mangosteen
(Guttiferae) India/Burma
Ceylon 1.12
Ebony
(Diospyros ebenum) Persimmon
(Ebenaceae) India
Ceylon 1.12
Mountain Mahogany
(Cercocarpus ledifolius) Rose
(Rosaceae) S.W. U.S.
Mexico 1.12
Black Ironwood
(Olea laurifolia) Olive (Oleaceae) South
Africa 1.11
Table 2. Fifteen[sic] of the world's heaviest ironwoods.
Some readers might wonder why I placed the South African black ironwood (Olea laurifolia) at the bottom of my list, while each year the Guinness Book of World Records lists this tree as the world's heaviest wood with a specific gravity of 1.49. In addition to the fact that most wood references do not concur with the Guinness Book, I studied a sample of this hardwood and the highest specific gravity I could obtain was 1.11, far below many other ironwoods. In fact, Acacia nigrescens (Acacia pallens), a common tree of the Kruger National Park region of South Africa, has a much heavier wood with a specific gravity of 1.19. Called knob-thorn acacia, the trunk is covered with woody, conical knobs each tipped with a thorn. Like other African acacias, the knob-thorn acacia is a painful tree to climb with bare hands. Some remarkable swollen-thorn acacias of Africa and Central America have hollowed-out thorns inhabited by symbiotic stinging ants that protect the trees from herbivores and epiphytes. According to Wood Density Phase 1--State of Knowledge, Australian Greenhouse Office, Technical Report No. 18 (Oct. 2000), there are several Acacia species in Australia that could be classified as ironwoods. Acacia xiphophylla has a specific gravity of 1.3 and another species called waddy wood (A. peuce) has a density of 1425. If this value is in kilograms per cubic meter, its specific gravity would be 1.425."