What you have in the picture is an older, 2-piece locking bolt. The newest locking bolts have the little buttons milled into the side, thus eliminating the "dumbell". The really old locking bolts were one-piece. Imaging what you have there as one piece with no split in the middle. They can be cantankerous on the newer frames.
Probably the reason you might have trouble with the newer "non-dumbell" bolts is a matter of a very tight fit within the frame. See the sticky at the top of this forum on "Fitting Contender barrels to G2 frames" Same thing applies to almost any barrel that will not lock up, or for that matter, any barrel that will not open easily.