Bullseye,
The Leupold matte VX-I and gloss VX-II are being offered to me at a very low price (my neighbor selling them will be having surgery soon). The VX-I is NIB and the VX-II (2004 model) has been used once. That is why they're being sold at the same price. I was originally going to buy a Nikon Prostaff.
Thanks for your feedback. A salesman told me that a matte finish was far better than a gloss finish in terms of durability, scratch resistance, etc. But, I felt like he was trying to offload a particular scope on me and wasn't being honest (he has been known to tell some tall tales to customers). All of my scopes so far have been passed down to me from relatives or were issued at work, so I've never picked one out on my own. I just want to make sure that I don't have a problem with my new scope out in the field.