Sean
The part about the 5 pounds I LIKE, a lot! The 7-30 Waters is a low recoiling round and will wallop the snot out of deer sized game with good shot placement. The bullets we have now allow the little 7mm to do proper stuff for a quick kill.
Just so long as one does not start tryin to pop deer way out there with it, it should do fine. That's why Glen got dissapointed with the 35 Rem. As luck would have it, he got a shot at a good deer way out there and he went for it. Bad results of course.
Glen is a big boy, and as such, he gets pounded HARD by rifles. The -06 is actually more gun than he is comfortable with. Maybe he could do a 308, or even a 7mm-08, both are good rounds.
Last I knew Carole was totin a chopped down 44 lever gun and she did just fine with it.
If you got the time an the froggies, go for it. And BTW, let us know how the project pans out :wink: