I always like the option of winning a firearm, but I also like off the wall stuff, things you would like to get, but due to the need to spend the money on other necessities, you will probably never buy. These kind of things are gift certificates to western stores, period canteens, a gourd canteen, leather accoutrements, heck even maybe tin coffee cups as door prizes. Like I said, guns are always great, but it definitely limits the number of prizes you can distribute, having one or two big prizes versus 10 medium prizes is really the club's call. Maybe even cruise some antique malls or flea markets and get some true period items, an afternoon of shopping may really pay off. I can also reccomend knives, I am a sucker for a beautiful blade.