Fred,
I go with about the same train of thought as you, in that I don't know much about hunting for trophys. Mostly I go out, and get a couple does, and am happy for the season. However, it would take about two deer to equal the size of yours. Most that I've taken, and seen taken in Ohio are about 120lb. hanging, or about 200ish live weight. Granted, there are some bruisers that weigh 250-300, but I haven't seen them. Also, at least here in Ohio, most of the time when people talk about dressed, they mean field dressed(no guts), that's why safetysheriff seemed a little suprised. Big bodied deer impress me...is there any way that you could post a pic. of the deer you talk about? Have a good 'un.
~~~Cattleskinner
P.S. Deer in Ohio also tend to hang at about 60% of their live weight, and processed are about 40% of their live weight.