Although I have not personally used any Mueller scopes yet, I totally agree with GB about the use of illuminated reticles during such low light conditions.
I have quite a few scopes with illuminated reticles: Leupold Vari-X III, Nikon Monarch, and Nightforce NXS. Out of the three, I like the Nightforce the best, but it is very heavy and very expensive (over $1,000). The Leupold and Nikon are not as expensive as the Nightforce, but they are still certainly way more than the $200 that you want to pay. As such, given that price range, and the good reviews that I have heard, I think that you should take a good look at the Mueller scope as well. It may well be an ideal choice for your hunting needs (and budget. :grin: )
Zachary