I recommend the 3 wt.
I have an Orvis HLS Rocky Mountain, 7', 4 pc, 5 wt which fishes very nicely on small streams. It is similar in action (Orvis scale mid-flex 5.5) to the super fines that replaced it in the Orvis line up followed by the Trout Bum series. I also use a nice 8' 2 wt Elk Horn when on small streams and delicacy of presentation becomes an issue. Besides, it's real grins to get a good sized fish on the 2 wt. That said, keep in mind that the 1 wt is a rod for small flies. You are going to lose some choices of what you can cast well when on the stream. The 3 wt would seem to me to be the better choice. I think these super fines are 8' rods?? I'm sorry, but I don't remember. You must also consider where it fits with your other rods. Does it fill a useful niche?
As to the price, if it's what you want, go for it. He isn't losing money @ $239, but it's all in what you want. I think these rods have a life time guarantee aslo.
Well, I hope this helps your thoughts.
Tight lines - Tapper