I have been to the skirmishers mortar shoot at ft. Shenandoah but found no one who knows anything about hern 8 inch mortars. Of course it's hard to talk to many folks who are shooting as they get pretty busy. I talked to Charlie Smithgalls regiment who shoots an origional 8 incher but found no one who knows much about big repro mortars. Paulson Brothers sells a repro. 8 incher for about $7500 and Herns is about $6050. Both seem to have good reputations? Is there a quality difference worth the extra $$. Who knows? I think both are made from gray iron. I can find no one who ownes either. I asked Hern for a list of some people who have bought theirs so I could talk to some owners and they said they would send me one but it hasn't happened so far.
I guess I thought that there would be lots of people out there who own reproduction 8 and 10 inch 1861 mortars, but maybe not?? Anyway I'm still leaning towards getting a 10 inch barrel ( I can make the carriage) if I can get one in the neighborhood of $5000 ( I may have that much saved by end of summer if all goes well) and if not I'll have to settle for an 8 incher. But from who and where, I don't know yet?
Scott