The Partition Golds in 2 3/4" 12ga have racked up a loooong list of one-shot bang-flops for me in recent years. In both my H&R Ultra Slug and my Savage 210 they will group into 2'' @ 100 yards, sometimes better.
The 3" version isn't doing quite as well in either gun, and the recoil is noticeably higher.
The Remingtons also fail to match the Winchesters for accurace in my two guns, but I have friends who find them better in their guns. There's another post on this site commenting on the better performance of the new technology Remingtons vs. the older Winchesters. I guess the answer is the same as it always is...try them for yourself to determine the best choice for you. None of them are bad, and they're all so much better than slugs and slug guns of 10 years ago that there's probably no bad choice.
John