I gotta pretty much agree with what's been said...ultimate choice of course depends on what fits her and how she shoots it. Most of all, I agree, that in close quarters, inside or outside, the short-barrelled shotgun is absolute tops. If she can handle it without the shoulder component of the stock, so much the better. I've even seen guys carry these concealed under a topcoat in the city, and I sure wouldn't want to offend one of 'em. This is done with a loop of leather from the buttstock around the shoulder, under the coat. If you practice, it's really fast, and very intimidating.