My handgun optics go all the way from red dots to assorted 2X, 2.5X8, and 3X9's. All work well if matched well with the caliber and game hunted. For what you're asking I'd go with the Leupold 2X. What I like about it on a short-range gun is the ease with which it brings all into view quickly and the crosshair is just right. Burris reticle is too skinny for quick or brush work. Red dots are really good, also, but have poor light gathering abilities. The dot shows up well but the field of view gets poor in low light. Bigger variables are great for longer range applications but not needed for close range shooting.